Judging (#newsHACK 2013)

For #newsHACK II (2014) please see this Judging page .

#newsHACK October 2013

Our esteemed Judges

  • Robin Pembrooke  - Head of BBC Future Media News & Weather
  • Nic Newman  - Independent Strategist, Trainer, and Product Tank Lead
  • Anthony Sullivan  - Head of Product, Guardian
  • Jon DiPaolo  - Executive Producer for SKY ONLINE
  • Chistina Scott  - Chief Information Officer, Financial Times
  • Peter Rippon  - Editor of Online Archive, BBC

Judging Criteria

The judges will be scoring hacks against the following five criteria.

  1. Working prototype:  Is it a working application or slideware? [yes/no]
  2. Relevance:  How well does the hack address one of our challenges?  [1-5]
  3. Value:  Does the hack solve a real user problem? How much value does it provide? [1-5]
  4. Innovation:  How original? How ambitious? [1-5]
  5. UX:  Does it provide a good user experience? [1-5]

Challenges Reminder

The entry categories are the following, though the judges will amend depending on the calibre of the entries. New categories may be added.

  1. Best Live & Breaking News Experience
  2. Best Visual News experience that scales
  3. Best use of Linked Data in Journalism tools
  4. Surprise Us!